Elite is going down this year cause of the Jordan stuff in 2k. And I get the feeling you guys havent played Live very much. Live has had better game play the last few years, and im not kidding. You can actually play defense in Live, you actually make contact with defenders when going to the paint, the computer doesnt let people walk prance into the paint at will. In 2k you drive baseline and get an easy layup, you can walk into the paint anytime you want and the computer wont ever try to play D, you can pretty much score all your points in the paint. For those of you in the OTR 2k10 league with me, you know what I mean. So yeah basically in Live you can actually play D, which gives it better game play I think. 2k has the better presentation and graphics by far, maybe not this year but in the last few years 2k easily has the advantage graphically. Its just the gameplay has always been underrated for Live.